“You Can’t Criticize Soldiers” Is How You Get the Worst People in Charge
On hierarchy as a shield, feedback as a necessity, and why pithy Reddit posts are a liability
There’s a story circulating right now about Graham Platner, a Maine Democratic Senate candidate and Marine combat veteran, who wrote on Reddit in 2019 that a wounded soldier “didn’t deserve to live.” The condemnations came fast. Robert O’Neill — the Navy SEAL credited with killing Osama bin Laden — called it “barbaric.” Susan Collins blasted it. Veterans lined up to say Platner is unfit for office.
They might be right. But the way the argument is being made carries its own risks — and tracing those risks is worth the effort.
In 2012, Pfc. Ted Daniels was caught on his own helmet cam being shot four times by Taliban fighters in Afghanistan. The footage went viral years later, garnering tens of millions of views. What the video looks like is a soldier making every tactical mistake in the book — running into the open, getting lit up, barely surviving.





























