Welfare for the Deserving
How Arizona’s school voucher program became the most expensive entitlement the anti-welfare crowd ever loved
There is a particular kind of American who believes deeply in self-reliance. He distrusts government handouts. He thinks welfare creates dependency. He has strong opinions about people who take public money for private choices. He voted for every candidate who promised to cut food stamps, reform Medicaid, and make people earn their benefits.
He also just applied for his child’s Empowerment Scholarship Account.
Arizona’s ESA program — a universal, no-income-limit transfer of state tax dollars to families who choose private or home education — is now approaching $1 billion per year in spending. It is, by any straightforward definition, a welfare program. It is a cash transfer from taxpayers to private individuals for a personal consumption choice. It has no means test. It is available to millionaires. And it is overwhelmingly used by people who were already making the choice it subsidizes.









































